10.2190/M8W4-JUYV-NB03-CUFL M8W4JUYVNB03CUFL 3 The Effect of Feedback and Social Reinforcement on Residential Electricity Consumption 215 227 20020509 20020509 20020509 20020509 M8W4JUYVNB03CUFL.pdf http://baywood.metapress.com/link.asp?target=contribution&id=M8W4JUYVNB03CUFL 3 Richard Katzev Laura Cooper Pat Fisher Reed College, Portland, Oregon This experiment explored the effect of informational feedback in reducing electrical energy consumption with eleven matched quads of all-electric apartments in Portland, Oregon. Feedback about KWH usage was provided from electrical meter readings during baseline, treatment and follow-up phases during the summer of 1977. Following a two week baseline period, apartments were exposed to one of the following conditions: (1) No treatment Control; (2) Daily Contingent Feedback, where informational feedback about KWH usage was provided on a daily basis; (3) Three Day Contingent Feedback Plus Decal, where feedback was provided every third day and commendation in the form of a decal was presented for reduced consumption; (4) Three Day Noncontingent Feedback Plus Decal, where feedback plus commendation were provided every third day, regardless of whether or not electricity consumption had decreased. Each of these feedback conditions had very little impact on electrical energy consumption during the two week treatment or the two week follow-up periods. These findings were viewed as consistent with other research which has also documented the limited impact of feedback on energy consumption. An analysis of the boundary conditions for the effectiveness of informational feedback stimuli was presented. R. A. Winett, S. Kaiser and G. Haberkorn, The Effects of Monetary Rebates and Daily Feedback on Electricity Conservation, <i>Journal of Environmental Systems, 6</i>, pp. 329-341, 1976-77. R. A. Winett, M. S. Neale, K. Williams, J. Yokley and H. Kauder, The Effects of Feedback on Residential Electricity Consumption: Three Replications, <i>Journal of Environmental Systems, 8</i>, pp. 217-233, 1978-79. L. McClelland, and S. W. Cook, Energy Conservation Effects of Continuous In-Home Feedback in All-Electric Homes, <i>Journal of Environmental Systems, 9</i>, pp. 169-173, 1979-80. J. J. Carlyle and E. S. Geller, Behavioral Approaches to Reducing Residential Energy Consumption: A Critical Review, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Unpublished manuscript. J. D. Cone and S. C. Hayes, Applied Behavior Analysis and the Solution of Environmental Problems, I. Altman and J. F. Wohlwill (eds.) <i>Human Behavior and Environment</i>, Volume 2, New York: Plenum Press, 1977. R. A. Winett and M. S. Neale, Psychological Framework for Energy Conservation in Buildings: Strategies, Outcomes, Directions, <i>Energy and Buildings, 2</i>, pp. 101-116, 1979. W. K. Estes, Reinforcement in Human Behavior, <i>American Scientist, 60</i>, pp. 723-729, 1972. R. B. Amnons, Effects of Knowledge of Performance: A Survey and Tentative Theoretical Formulation, <i>Journal of General Psychology, 54</i>, pp. 279-299, 1956. E. A. Locke, N. Cartledge and J. Koeppel, Motivational Effects of Knowledge of Results: A Goal-Setting Phenomenon?, <i>Psychological Bulletin, 70</i>, pp. 474-485, 1968. S. C. Hayes and J. D. Cone, Reducing Residential Electrical Energy Use: Payments, Information and Feedback, <i>Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 10</i>, pp. 425-435, 1977. R. A. Winett, J. H. Kagel, R. C. Battalio and R. C. Winkler, Effects of Monetary Rebates, Feedback, and Information on Residential Electricity Conservation, <i>Journal of Applied Psychology, 63</i>, pp. 73-80, 1978. L. J. Becker and C. Seligman, Reducing Air Conditioning Waste by Signalling It Is Cool Outside, <i>Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 4</i>, pp. 412-415, 1978. S. C. Hayes and J. D. Cone, Reduction of Residential Consumption of Electricity Through Simple Monthly Feedback, <i>Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis</i>, in press. M. H. Palmer, M. E. Lloyd and K. E. Lloyd, An Experimental Analysis of Electricity Conservation Procedures, <i>Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 10</i>, pp. 665-672, 1978. R. A. Winett, M. S. Neale and H. C. Grier, Effects of Self-Monitoring and Feedback on Residential Electricity Consumption, <i>Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 12</i>, pp. 173-184, 1979. C. Seligman and J. M. Darley, Feedback as a Means of Decreasing Residential Energy Consumption, <i>Journal of Applied Psychology, 62</i>, pp. 363-368, 1977. C. Seligman, J. M. Darley and L. J. Becker, Psychological Strategies to Reduce Energy Consumption: First Annual Progress Report, 1976, Center for Environmental Studies, Princeton University, Princeton, N. J. Unpublished manuscript. W. B. Seaver and A. H. Patterson, Decreasing Fuel-Oil Consumption Through Feedback and Social Commendation, <i>Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 9</i>, pp. 147-152, 1976. L. J. Becker, The Joint Effect of Feedback and Goal Setting on Performance: A Field Study of Residential Energy Consumption, <i>Journal of Applied Psychology, 63</i>, pp. 428-433, 1978. R. Kohlenberg, T. Phillips and W. Proctor, A Behavioral Analysis of Peaking in Residential Electrical-Energy Consumers, <i>Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 9</i>, pp. 13-18, 1976. R. J. Kohlenberg, C. H. Martin, R. Barach, and S. Anschell, Interim Report on the Effects of Alternative Rates and Feedback on Residential Electricity Consumption: An Experimental Analysis, 1976, University of Washington, Seattle, WA. Unpublished manuscript. D. J. Bem, Self-perception theory. L. Berkowitz (ed.), <i>Advances in Experimental Social Psychology.</i> Vol. 6. New York: Academic Press, 1972. S. Siegel, <i>Nonparametric Statistics for the Behavioral Sciences</i>, New York: McGraw-Hill, 1956. H. H. Kelley, Attribution Theory in Social Psychology, <i>Nebraska Symposium on Motivation, 14</i>, pp. 192-238, 1967. E. E. Jones, D. E. Kanouse, H. H. Kelley, R. E. Nisbett, S. Valins and B. Weiner, <i>Attribution: Perceiving the Causes of Behavior.</i> New York: General Learning Press, 1972.