10.2190/RB1V-UV02-XTBK-FBKY RB1VUV02XTBKFBKY 5 A Prospective: Leisure Planning 193 203 20020509 20020509 20020509 20020509 RB1VUV02XTBKFBKY.pdf http://baywood.metapress.com/link.asp?target=contribution&id=RB1VUV02XTBKFBKY 2 David L. Groves School of Health, Physical Education and Recreation, Bowling Green State University This article explores types of models for better leisure planning. Each of the traditional models recognizes and defends a particular content position. A process model is proposed to incorporate the different positions. Each of the content models have strengths that should be included for effective leisure planning. M. J. Breheny and P. W. J. Batey, The History of Planning Methodology: A Preliminary Sketch, <i>Built Environment, 7</i>:2, pp. 109-120, 1981. A. J. Veal, <i>Planning for Leisure Alternative Approaches</i>, Papers in Leisure Studies No. 5, Polytechnic of North London, London, 1982. M. Miller, The Roots of Planning, <i>The Planner, 70</i>:9, pp. 11-15, 1984. R. Kaplan, Citizen Participation in the Design of a Park, <i>Environment and Behavior, 12</i>:4, pp. 494-507, 1980. J. Ash, Public Participation: Time to Bury Skeffington, <i>The Planner, 65</i>:4, pp. 136-139, 1979. J. J. Dinkel and J. H. Clark, Planning for Recreational Planning, <i>Socio-Economic Planning Science, 75</i>, pp. 139-146, 1981. A. Faludi, Towards a Three-Dimensional Model of Planning Behavior, <i>Environment and Planning, 3</i>, pp. 253-266, 1971. G. H. Stankey, J. C. Hendee, and R. N. Clark, Commentary: Applied Social Research Can Improve Public Participation in Resource Decision Making, <i>Rural Sociology, 40</i>:1, pp. 67-74, 1975. R. Michael, Greening the Inner City, <i>The Planner, 70</i>:7, pp. 17-18, 1984. R. Stirrat, Urban Forestry, <i>The Planner, 70</i>:7, p. 19, 1984. J. Gyford, Planning with Personalities and Politics in Mind, <i>The Planner, 66</i>:1, pp. 12-14, 1980. R. G. Walsh, N. P. Miller, and L. O. Gilliam, Congestion and Willingness to Pay for Expansion of Skiing Capacity, <i>Land Economics, 59</i>:2, pp. 195-210, 1983. P. Dearden and L. Rosenblood, Some Observations on Multivariate Techniques in Landscape Evaluation, <i>Regional Studies, 14</i>, pp. 99-110, 1980. D. S. Brookshire, L. S. Eubanks, and A. Randall, Estimating Option Prices and Existence Values for Wildlife Resources, <i>Land Economies, 59</i>:1, pp. 1-15, 1983. R. J. Marshall and I. Masser, British Planning Methodology: Three Historical Perspectives, <i>Built Environment, 7</i>:2, pp. 121-129, 1981. U. S. G. A. O., <i>Need to Reexamine the Federal Role in Planning, Selecting, and Funding State and Local Parks</i>, CED-81-32, The Comptroller General of the United States, Report to the Congress of the United States, U. S. General Accounting Office, Gaithersburg, Maryland, 1981. H. J. Ewers and R. W. Wettmann, Innovation-Oriented Regional Policy, <i>Regional Studies, 14</i>, pp. 161-179, 1980. I. Masser, The Analysis of Planning Processes — Some Methodological Considerations, <i>Environment and Planning, 9</i>:1, pp. 5-14, 1982. P. H. Bly and F. V. Webster, Land Use/Transport Models: How Effective Are They?, <i>Ekistics, 51</i>:305, pp. 147-151, 1984. J. Kolzlowski and J. T. Hughes, <i>Threshold Analysis: A Quantitative Planning Method</i>, Architectural Press, London, 1972. A. T. Purcell, Multivariate Models and the Attributes of the Experience of the Built Environment, <i>Planning and Design, 11</i>, pp. 193-212, 1984. D. Zumkeller and W. Brog, Reflections on Recent Approaches to Transport Modelling, <i>Ekistics, 51</i>:305, pp. 155-160, 1984. P. H. Rees, Multiregional Mathematical Demography: Themes and Issues, <i>Environment and Planning, 15</i>, pp. 1571-1583, 1983. M. L. Cropper, The Value of Urban Amenities, <i>Journal of Regional Science, 21</i>:3, pp. 359-374, 1981. M. G. Ragheb and J. G. Beard, Measuring Leisure Attitude, <i>Journal of Leisure Research, 14</i>:2, pp. 155-167, 1982. P. Gordon and J. Ledent, Modeling the Dynamics of a System of Metropolitan Areas: A Demoeconomic Approach, <i>Environment and Planning, 12</i>, pp. 125-133, 1980. S. B. Lieber and D. R. Fesenmaier, Modelling Recreation Choice: A Case Study of Management Alternatives in Chicago, <i>Regional Studies, 18</i>, pp. 31-43, 1984. L. Dominsuez and W. Page, Use and Misuse of Social Stratification in Consumer Behavior Research, <i>Journal of Business Research, 9</i>, pp. 151-173, 1981. S. L. Percy, Citizen Participation in the Coproduction of Urban Services, <i>Urban Affairs Quarterly, 19</i>:4, pp. 431-446, 1984. T. L. Burton, Identification of Recreation Types Through Cluster Analysis, <i>Society and Leisure, 3</i>, pp. 47-64, 1971. R. B. Peiser, Financial Feasibility Models in New Town Development: Risk Evaluation in the United States, <i>Town Planning Review, 55</i>, pp. 75-90, 1984. R. B. Peiser, Land Use Versus Road Network Design in Community Transport Cost Evaluation, <i>Land Economics, 60</i>:1, pp. 95-109, 1984. B. Haber, Citizen Participation in New York City Government, <i>Journal of the Urban Planning and Development, 108</i>, pp. 11-14, 1982. J. L. Brudney and R. E. England, Analyzing Citizen Evaluation of Municipal Services: A Dimensional Approach, <i>Urban Affairs Quarterly, 17:17</i>:3, pp. 359-370, 1982. R. Courbis, Measuring Effects of French Regional Policy by Means of a Regional-National Model, <i>Regional Science and Urban Economics, 2</i>, pp. 59-79, 1982. W. J. Milne, N. J. Glickman, and F. G. Adams, Symposium on Multiregional Forecasting and Policy Simulation Models, A Framework for Analyzing Regional Growth and Decline: A Multiregion Econometric Model of the United States, <i>Journal of Regional Science, 20</i>:2, pp. 173-189, 1980. D. Cowell, The Role of Market Research in the Development of Public Policy in the Field of Recreation and Leisure, <i>Journal of the Market Research Society, 23</i>:2, pp. 72-83, 1981. A. D. Sorenser, Towards a Market Theory of Planning, <i>The Planner, 69</i>:3, pp. 78-80, 1983. A. W. Evans, A Methodological Note on the Use of Regression Equations for the Purpose of Stimulating Change in Urban Location Patterns, <i>Environment and Planning, 12</i>, pp. 921-926, 1980. J. Smith, Threshold Analysis of Two Potential Metropolitan Growth Corridors, <i>Town Planning Review, 53</i>:2, pp. 200-214, 1982. R. E. C. M. van der Heijden and H. J. P. Timmermans, Modeling Choice-Set-Generating Processes via Stepwise Logit Regression Procedures: Some Empirical Results, <i>Environment and Planning, 16</i>, pp. 1249-1255, 1984. B. E. Tonn, A Sociopsychological Contribution to the Theory of Individual Time-Allocation, <i>Environment and Planning, 16</i>, pp. 201-223, 1984. V. Jain and A. N. Christakis, A Systemic Assessment and Application of the Ekistics Typology, <i>Ekistics, 285</i>, pp. 464-470, November/December 1980. F. C. Menz and J. K. Mullen, Expected Encounters and Willingness to Pay for Outdoor Recreation, <i>Land Economics, 57</i>:1, pp. 33-40, 1981. W. M. Rohe, Social Impact Analysis and the Planning Process in the United States: A Review and Critique, <i>Town Planning Review, 53</i>:4, pp. 367-382, 1982. R. L. Burford and J. L. Katz, A Method for Estimation of Input-Output-Type Output Multipliers When No I-O Model Exists, <i>Journal of Regional Science, 21</i>:2, pp. 151-161, 1981. W. J. Gillen and A. Guccione, Interregional Feedbacks in Input-Output Models: Some Formal Results, <i>Journal of Regional Science, 20</i>:4, pp. 477-482, 1980. M. Oelschlaeger, Cost-Benefit Analysis: A Philosophical Reconsideration, <i>Ekistics, 46</i>:216, pp. 171-175, 1979. J. R. Hamilton and R. C. Jensen, Summary Measures of Interconnectedness for Input Output Models, <i>Environment and Planning, 15</i>, pp. 55-65, 1983. W. P. MacConnell, Massachusetts Map Down, Land-Use and Vegetative Cover Mapping Classification Manual for Use with Massachusetts Map Down Maps, Planning and Resource Development Series No. 25, Holdsworth Natural Resources Center, Publication No. 97, Cooperative Extension Service, University of Massachusetts, December 1973. L. Fahey, W. R. King, and V. K. Narayanan, Environmental Scanning and Forecasting in Strategic Planning - The State of the Art, <i>Long Range Planning, 14</i>:2, pp. 32-39, 1981. I. Majid, J. A. Sinden, and A. Randall, Benefit Evaluation of Increments to Existing Systems of Public Facilities, <i>Land Economics, 59</i>:4, pp. 377-392, 1983. L. Bach, Locational Models for Systems of Private and Public Facilities Based on Concepts of Accessibility and Access Opportunity, <i>Environment and Planning, 12</i>, pp. 301-320, 1980. M. J. Ferguson, A Strategic Choice Approach to Recreation Site Resource Allocation, <i>Town Planning Review, 50</i>:3, pp. 325-345, 1979. H. N. Van Lier and F. R. Steiner, A Review of the Zuiderzee Reclamation Works: An Example of Dutch Physical Planning, <i>Landscape Planning, 9</i>, pp. 35-59, 1982. J. L. Altmann and J. S. DeSalvo, Tests and Extensions of the Mills-Muth Simulation Model of Urban Residential Land Use, <i>Journal of Regional Science, 21</i>:1, pp. 1-21, 1981. D. T. Kresge and P. O. Roberts, <i>System Analysis and Simulation Models</i>, Transportation Research Program, Brookings Institution, Washington, D. C., 1971. S. Openshaw, A Methodology for Using Models for Planning Purposes, <i>Environment and Planning, 11</i>, pp. 879-896, 1979. G. B. Hall and S. M. Taylor, A Causal Model of Attitudes Toward Mental Health Facilities, <i>Environment and Planning, 15</i>, pp. 525-542, 1983. G. Hyman and D. Palmer, A Causal Analysis of Unemployment and Vacancies in British Regions 1969-1974, <i>Regional Studies, 14</i>, pp. 353-365, 1980. Y. S. Popkov, Simulation and Analysis of Structural Properties of Human Settlement Systems by Means of Entropy Maximizing Models, <i>Environment and Planning, 12</i>, pp. 1165-1190, 1980. H. Weihrich, The TOWS Matrix - A Tool for Situational Analysis, <i>Long Range Planning, 15</i>:2, pp. 54-66, 1982. R. Altman, D. Harris, and M. Hill, The Impact of Public Participation on Planning: The Case of the Derbyshire Structure Plan, <i>Town Planning Review, 55</i>, pp. 177-196, 1984. M. C. Poulton, A Land Use Evaluation Technique for Decision Makers, <i>Regional Studies, 16</i>:2, pp. 85-96, 1982. J. C. Moughton, G. Ceccarelli, and E. Stratton, Planning for Real, <i>Town and Country Planning, 49</i>:1, pp. 13-14, 1980. J. Saltman and L. G. Carr, Action Research on Redlining: Methodological Weakness, Socio-Political Strengths, <i>Urban Affairs, Papers, 2</i>:4, pp. 20-35, 1980. Davies, W. K. D., Higher-Order Factor Analysis and Functional Regionalization: A Case Study in South Wales, 1971, <i>Environment and Planning, 12</i>, pp. 685-701, 1980. White, P., Urban Planning in Britain and the Soviet Union: A Comparative Analysis of Two Planning Systems, <i>Town Planning Review, 51</i>:7, pp. 211-226, 1980. Willis, K. G. and K. J. Thomson, Decision Optimising Technique, <i>Town Planning Review, 51</i>:1, pp. 67-75, 1980. Yecheskel, The Quality of Life in Los Angeles, <i>Ekistics, 46</i>:278, pp. 281-286, 1979.